How to compare before and after your processing at the same loudness
When you add an EQ, a compressor or a limiter, the result is often a little louder. A louder version tends to sound better on first listen, even when nothing else improved. So if you switch between before and after without matching the level, you are partly judging the volume.
A fair check has three parts: put both at the same loudness, switch between them while the song keeps playing, and, if you want to set your expectations aside, hide which one is which.
What you need
- A DAW that runs AU, VST3 or AAX plug-ins (see the DAW list in the README)
- Kirin Hypha, a free, open-source plug-in for macOS and Windows
Measuring, listening and blind tests in Hypha need no account, no Kirin OS and no internet connection.
1. Put PRE before and POST after the processing
Insert Hypha's PRE before the plug-ins you want to judge, and POST after them. With one PRE in the project, POST pairs with it automatically when you open its window. POST then shows both readings and the difference.
2. Match the loudness and listen
On POST, press LISTEN. You can now switch between PRE and POST while the song plays.
Press MATCH. Hypha measures the latest four seconds and sets PRE to POST's loudness. If raising PRE would push its true peak past the ceiling, you choose: lower POST to match, or raise PRE only up to the ceiling.
With the level difference gone, what you hear is what the processing changed. After you change the chain, run MATCH again for a new measurement. END returns POST to its original level.
3. Hide the names
BLIND keeps the matched level and hides the names. Switch between SOURCE 1 and SOURCE 2 as often as you like. Once both have sounded, REVEAL shows which was before and which was after.
For a stricter check, set ROUNDS to 5 or 10. You pick the one you prefer in each round, and the positions are shuffled between rounds. The result shows how many times you chose each side. When one side leads by two or more, it also shows how often a result at least this uneven would happen by chance. Hypha does not store your answers. It is not an ABX test.
More on blind tests: How to run a blind A/B test on your mix at matched loudness.
Two plug-ins, or outboard against a plug-in
The same idea works for two processors. Put PRE1, A, PRE2, B and POST in that order on one track. Put outboard gear on a hardware insert in A and a plug-in in B (two plug-ins work the same way), press A/B on POST and choose PRE2. LISTEN, MATCH and BLIND then compare A and B at the same loudness.
Leave it in the session
Hypha is light enough to stay in the session while you work. In normal use, expect roughly 0–1% on the DAW CPU meter; the value varies with the DAW, sample rate, buffer size and the number of active pairs. Without PRE, POST on a bus or the master still shows loudness, True Peak and crest.